Go a size up...or two. Had to give it to my wife. My three other hoodies all fit the same. This one was tight on my forearms. My three others: degrassi, camp caribou and Beetlejuice. All XL. (I'm 6'2, 250lbs)
Since there are no refunds or exchanges, I hope this helps at least one person. Lol
Edit: Steve, *ultra enthusiastic high five* you da man!